racktr

Cheap domains and the renewal trap

Domain prices are built to look good on the first year. Registrars often sell new domains below cost and make it back on renewals, so the price you see when you search may be one you never pay again. Of the 315 prices racktr tracks across 7 registrars, 144 renew at twice the first-year price or more. The steepest: .store at Gandi, $1.99 the first year and $159.98 every year after.

First year against five years

EndingCheapest first yearCheapest over 5 years
.app$7.99 at Hostinger, then $19.99/yr$68.47 at Porkbun
.biz$6.69 at Porkbun, then $19.05/yr$82.89 at Porkbun
.blog$1.99 at Hostinger, then $29.99/yr$86.50 at Porkbun
.ca$5.00 at IONOS, then $15.00/yr$45.17 at Porkbun
.cloud$1.00 at IONOS, then $37.00/yr$87.89 at OVHcloud
.co$6.49 at Hostinger, then $34.99/yr$140.56 at Porkbun
.com$0.01 at Hostinger with 3 years paid up front, then $19.99/yr$59.05 at Porkbun
.de$1.99 at Hostinger, then $13.99/yr$18.90 at INWX
.dev$7.99 at Hostinger, then $18.99/yr$60.23 at Porkbun
.in$0.01 at Hostinger with 3 years paid up front, then $9.99/yr$30.00 at IONOS
.info$1.40 at IONOS, then $35.00/yr$92.16 at Porkbun
.io$26.99 at Hostinger, then $74.99/yr$235.32 at Porkbun

Prices are in US dollars, without VAT. For 11 of these 12 endings, the registrar with the lowest first-year price is not the cheapest one to keep the domain at for 5 years.

The small print on first-year prices

166 of the prices come with a condition. The common ones:

  • New customers only, often for your first domain and no more.
  • A multi-year registration. The low price applies only if you pay two or three years up front; the later years are charged at the renewal price.
  • A sale with an end date. Fine if you register now, gone if you come back next week.

racktr shows the condition next to each price, and counts it in the multi-year totals: a promo that needs a three-year registration doesn't lower the one-year cost.

How to pay less

  • Compare the renewal price, not the first year, unless the domain is for a short project.
  • Take the promo, then transfer. Moving a domain to another registrar usually costs about a year's renewal and adds that year to it, so you can register where it's cheapest and move to where renewing is.
  • Prefer the classic endings for anything long-lived. Newer ones like .shop, .store or .tech are often the cheapest to start and the dearest to keep.

The domain price comparison sorts every registrar by the cost of 1, 2 or 5 years for any ending, with renewals included.