racktr

VPS or dedicated server: where dedicated becomes worth it

A VPS is a slice of a big machine: you get some of its cores, memory and disk, and share the rest with other customers. A dedicated server is the whole machine. The usual advice is to start on a VPS and move to dedicated when you outgrow it. The prices tell a more interesting story: of the 856 plans racktr lists, 191 are dedicated servers, and some of them cost less than a virtual server with the same memory.

Cheapest of each, by memory

RAMCheapest VPSCheapest dedicated
4 GB+OVHcloud VPS-1, 4 GB: $5.35Scaleway Dedibox Start-1-M-SATA, 8 GB: $5.51
8 GB+Contabo Cloud VPS 4, 8 GB: $6.60Scaleway Dedibox Start-1-M-SATA, 8 GB: $5.51
16 GB+Contabo Cloud VPS 8, 24 GB: $16.80OVHcloud KS-B, 32 GB: $10.00
32 GB+Contabo Cloud VPS 12, 48 GB: $30.00OVHcloud KS-B, 32 GB: $10.00
64 GB+Contabo Cloud VPS 16, 64 GB: $44.50OVHcloud KS-6, 128 GB: $44.00
128 GB+none listedOVHcloud KS-6, 128 GB: $44.00

Prices are per month, before tax and extras. From 8 GB of memory up, the cheapest dedicated server costs no more than the cheapest VPS.

Why cheap dedicated servers are cheap

Providers keep older machines in service long after they are paid off, and rent them out for little. The Scaleway Dedibox Start-1-M-SATA above, for example, runs on an Intel C2750 (Avoton) with 1 TB of HDD storage. That buys you a lot of memory and cores that nobody else uses, but each core is slower than a current one, and 32 of the dedicated plans listed have only spinning disks, no SSD. 160 of all 191 charge a setup fee, and a dedicated server takes hours or days to deliver instead of seconds.

When to pick which

  • Pick a VPS if you want to start small, resize in a click, take snapshots, or move between regions. For most websites and apps under 16 GB it is the simpler choice.
  • Pick a dedicated server if you need steady CPU all day (builds, encoding, game servers, databases), lots of memory or disk for the money, or no noisy neighbours. Check the CPU model and disk type before you buy: two dedicated servers at the same price can be a decade apart.

You can compare both side by side on the listings: filter by dedicated or VPS, set a minimum RAM, and sort by total cost to count setup fees and extras. For memory sizes on the VPS side, see the cheapest VPS for each amount of memory.